Evaluation of an Argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 1

Evaluation of an Argument - Essay Example The essay "Evaluation of an Argument" evaluates the validity, degree of soundness, and truth of the premises of the following argument: some sound arguments are valid, some valid arguments are arguments with false premises, some arguments with false premises are arguments with mood and figure OAO-2. According to Hyde, a syllogism refers to a deductive argument comprising of a minor premise, major premise, and a conclusion. The first syllogism for the above argument, which we have established to be a sprite can be deduced as: some arguments with mood and figure OAO-2 are not sound, some valid arguments are not sound, some arguments with false premises are not sound, no arguments with false premises are valid. In the general sense, the conventional logic expression of this argument: some T is not Q, some F is not Q, T is not F. The second syllogism for the original argument can be deductively interpreted within the context of the sortie to imply that: no arguments with false premises a re valid, some arguments underpinned with false premises are not sound, all arguments with mood and figure OAO-2 are generally not sound. Therefore, in the second syllogism, the conclusion of the original argument being evaluated has been transformed into a portion of the second syllogism. Moreover, the changed premise of the original automatically became an intermediate conclusion for the second syllogism. The example shows the unique character in which sorites tend to change the premise.